What appears to be a pumpkin pie is topped off with two lookalike cat figurines, alongside the message, “Happy Thanksgiving Birthday,” which, we’ll be honest, must be some kind of inside joke.
Swift, for one, was laughing. “Blake wins at birthday pies. @blakelively I honestly can’t stop laughing rn,” Swift shared on Instagram alongside a photo of the pie. Aunt Blake obviously understands Meredith and Olivia.